The California Coastal Commission has postponed a decision on a proposed Orange County Public Works sand replenishment project. The commission considered the matter on Thursday, Nov. 5, but did not make a decision. Coastal Commission staff have recommended approval.
Seal Beach is a co-applicant for the project, along with the Orange County Public Works Department, as well as the cities of Huntington Beach, Newport Beach, San Clemente, and the California State Parks agency.
The county proposes a “10-year program of intermittent beach nourishment known as the Sand Compatibility and Opportunistic Use Program” at 25 receiver beaches, including Seal Beach, according to the unsigned Coastal Commission staff report.
“The OC Sand Compatibility and Opportunistic Use Program (SCOUP) is intended to establish regulatory approvals in advance to allow for beach nourishment projects to occur as source sediment opportunities arise,” according to the report.
“The subject permit is only for sand replenishment/deposition projects; except for Huntington Beach State Beach back beach which is proposed as a sand source site; otherwise the removal/excavation of all other source sediments would be separately approved by local, state, and federal agencies as appropriate. Without the pre-approved SCOUP, beach compatible sediment would otherwise go to landfill or be utilized in construction, rather than being beneficially re-used on OC beaches,” according to the report.
“The purpose of the program is to provide the County of Orange and other sediment managers with a larger degree of flexibility that will ultimately allow for greater success in implementation of beneficial re-use of sediments from the 380 miles of flood control channels, numerous sediment detention basins, creeks, estuaries, ocean outlets, and four dams managed and maintained by OCPW,” according to the report.
“The SCOUP would allow for a range of beach nourishment projects from small-scale (1,00-5,000 cu. yds.) up to a large-scale project with a maximum of 300,000 cu. yds. Of material placement,” according to the report.
Sand would be delivered by truck, according to the report.
“Sand placement is proposed year-round but would mostly likely occur in the fall and winter months to avoid disturbing beach users during the peak beach use season (Memorial Day to Labor Day),” according to the report.
An Oct. 30 letter from Nancy Okada of the Sierra Club raised concerns about the potential impact of the project on Bolsa Chica State Beach. “We request revisions to the proposed approval of OC SCOUP to protect Huntington State Beach from inadequately defined sand extraction and associated impacts on public access, recreation, and park resources,” Okada wrote.
Okada argued that removing sand from a public beach was diffeernt from using sand taken from flood-control maintenance.
“Huntington State Beach should not become a recurring source of sand for numerous receiving jurisdictions without enforceable extraction limits, adequate monitoring, protection of visitors, and expressed control by California State Parks,” Okada wrote.
Her group’s requests included:
• Cumulative donor-site extraction limits covering all receiving beaches
• Knowing who measures beach conditions and who enforces the limits
• Protection of the beach experience and public parking
• Protection of State Parks’ authority to limit or end sand donor operations
• Applying habitat protections to the project
Capistrano Bay District Manager Donal S. Russell, in a separate letter, requested that Capistrano Bay District be added to the list of receiver sites.



